More Information | Pizza Mill

Our Pizza’s are made to order, which means you can customize your pizza just the way you like it. We also offer the option to have the pizza made as a half and half.

The Pizza Mill is not a gluten-free restaurant and cannot ensure that cross contamination will never occur. We have processes in place to minimize cross-contamination. All gluten free items are prepared in the same oven and on the same workspace. We do our best to keep everything separate. We cannot guarantee your food will not be cross contaminated. We fry our fried options in Beef Tallow. All fried items are fried in the same fryer.

We love feeding large groups! Please provide us with as much notice as possible (via phone or email) for orders of more than 10 pizzas. Orders with more than 6 pizzas, please provide us with 2 hour notice, if possible.

We offer indoor and outdoor seating. Our patio is pet friendly and can seat approximately 24 people. Our dining room is very cozy, we can only seat 20 people inside. Being that we are such a small restaurant, 85%+ of our orders are take out or delivery.

Given our small size, we can only make so much food at a time. During peak eating hours, we do our very best to keep the wait times as low as possible. For that reason, we can’t always get to every phone call and online ordering wait times may be extended to accommodate customers as efficiently as possible. We recommend ordering ahead of time online or by phone.

Unfortunately, due to our size and dining style. We do not offer a reservation option. You are welcome to call shortly before your arrival to see if we have seating available though! We also are able to provide disposable dinnerware upon request, perfect for a lovely Black Hills Picnic. There are many wonderful parks and public lands within minutes of the Pizza Mill.

We offer an ever evolving -variety of local Craft Beer, Pepsi Products, Bottled Tea and Bottled Lemonade.