Skip to main
Pizza Mill
  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Mill Favorite Pizza Combinations
  • Build Your Own Pizza
  • Sandwiches
  • Pasta and Lite Options
  • Salads
  • Beverages
  • Extra Sauces
  • Pizza Mill Retail

Pizza Mill Menu

904 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD

904 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD

·

  • Most orderedCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Mill Favorite Pizza Combinations
  • Build Your Own Pizza
  • Sandwiches
  • Pasta and Lite Options
  • Salads
  • Beverages
  • Extra Sauces
  • Pizza Mill Retail

Most ordered

  • Towering Timber.

    Towering Timber

    $12.99+

  • Build Your Own Pizza - Medium 12”.

    Build Your Own Pizza - Medium 12”

    $17.99+

  • Build Your Own Pizza - Extra Large 16”.

    Build Your Own Pizza - Extra Large 16”

    $21.99+

  • Hearty Logger (All Meat).

    Hearty Logger (All Meat)

    $12.99+

  • The Buzzsaw Pizza.

    The Buzzsaw Pizza

    $12.99+

  • Hungry Hawaiian.

    Hungry Hawaiian

    $12.99+

  • Cheesy Bread.

    Cheesy Bread

    $14.99+

  • Chicken Wings.

    Chicken Wings

    $14.99

Appetizers

Start your meal off with one of our delicious appetizers!

Cheesy Bread

$14.99+

Ten rectangular slices of cheesy goodness made from a 12\" pizza crust, topped with seasonings and cheese, served with Ranch and Marinara. Gluten Free available for $15.99.

Cheesy Bread.

Onion Rings

$9.50

An appetizer size order of deep fried, beer battered onion rings.

Chicken Wings

$14.99

Eight deep fried breaded, bone-in wings with your choice of sauce on the side. Sauce options: Buffalo, BBQ, Ranch, Garlic Parmesan, Mango Habanero.

Chicken Wings.

Garlic Bread

$6.50

Four slices of Texas Toast style garlic bread served with Ranch and Marinara.

Garlic Bread.

Mill Favorite Pizza Combinations

Extra Large 16" (10 Slices), Medium 12" (8 Slices), Personal 8" (4 Slices), Gluten Free 10" (8 Slices), Calzone, and Flatbread. Each additional topping charged unless substituted.

Healthy Logger (All Veggie)

$12.99+

Mushroom, Black Olive, Onion, Green & Red Pepper on a base of Marinara.

Hearty Logger (All Meat)

$12.99+

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Beef & Canadian Bacon on a base of Marinara.

Hearty Logger (All Meat).

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$12.99+

Roasted Chicken Breast, Bacon and Ranch Dressing on a base of Marinara.

Chicken Bacon Ranch.

The Buzzsaw Pizza

$12.99+

Fully loaded with Pepperoni on a base of Marinara topped with our house blend of cheese.

The Buzzsaw Pizza.

Towering Timber

$12.99+

Pepperoni, Bacon, Beef, Canadian Bacon, Italian Sausage, Onion, Mushroom, Black Olive, Green & Red Pepper on a base of Marinara.

Towering Timber.

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

$12.99+

Chicken, Onion, Tomato, Artichoke Hearts and Spinach on a base of Alfredo Sauce.

Chicken Alfredo Pizza.

The Big Frog

$12.99+

Canadian Bacon, Sauerkraut, Black Olive & Green Olive on a base of Marinara.

The Sawmill Pizza (Cheeseburger Pizza)

$12.99+

Ground Beef, Onion, and Pickle on a base of Thousand Island Sauce.

The Sawmill Pizza (Cheeseburger Pizza).

Spinach Artichoke

$12.99+

Spinach & Artichoke Hearts on a base of house prepared Garlic White Sauce. Can be made with or without Chicken.

Spinach Artichoke.

Ultimate Reuben Pizza

$13.99+

Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Onion, Green Pepper, Green Olive & Jalapeno on a base of house prepared Garlic White Sauce & Thousand Island Sauce.

Ultimate Reuben Pizza.

Roasted Ponderosa

$12.99+

Beef OR Roasted Chicken Breast, Onion, Green Pepper, Tomato and Jalapeno on a base of Marinara.

BBQ Chicken

$12.99+

Roasted Chicken Breast, Onion & Green Olive on a base of BBQ Sauce.

BBQ Chicken.

Hungry Hawaiian

$12.99+

Canadian Bacon, Bacon, Pineapple, Black Olive and Banana Pepper on a base of Marinara.

Hungry Hawaiian.

The Pickle Pizza

$12.99+

Pickle, Bacon, Onion & Crushed Red Pepper Flakes on a base of Garlic White Sauce.

Gyro Pizza

$12.99+

Thin sliced Gyro Meat on a base of Tzatziki Sauce topped with Fresh Greens & Tomato.

Gyro Pizza.

Buffalo Chicken

$12.99+

Chicken, Onion, Black Olive and Bacon on a base of cheese and Buffalo Sauce.

Buffalo Chicken.

Holy Jalapeno

$12.99+

Beef, Bacon, Onion, Green Chilis and Jalapeno on a base of house prepared Garlic White Sauce, topped with house blended cheese.

12" Half & Half Mill Favorites

$25.99

Pick two Mill Favorite specialties, one for each half, on our 12" Medium crust.

12" Half & Half Mill Favorites.

16" Half & Half Mill Favorites

$30.99

Pick two Mill Favorite specialties, one for each half, on our 16" Extra Large crust.

16" Half & Half Mill Favorites.

Gluten Free Half & Half Mill Favorites

$26.99

Pick two Mill Favorite specialties, one for each half, on our 10" gluten free crust.

Build Your Own Pizza

Build your Pizza the way you like it!

Build Your Own Pizza - Extra Large 16”

$21.99+

Extra Large 16” (10 Slices) with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $2.90 each.

Build Your Own Pizza - Extra Large 16”.

Build Your Own Pizza - Medium 12”

$17.99+

Medium 12” (8 Slices) with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $2.60 each.

Build Your Own Pizza - Medium 12”.

Build Your Own Pizza - Personal 8”

$10.99+

Personal 8" (4 Slices) with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $1.55 each.

Build Your Own Pizza - Gluten Free 10”

$18.99+

Gluten Free 10” (8 Slices) with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $2.60 each.

Build Your Own Pizza - Gluten Free 10”.

Build Your Own Calzone

$14.99+

Calzone with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $2.10 each.

Build Your Own Calzone.

Build Your Own Flatbread

$10.99+

Flatbread with sauce and cheese. Add your toppings at $1.55 each.

Build Your Own Flatbread.

Sandwiches

Each sandwich is served with French Fries or a Side Salad. Onion Rings can be added for $2.99.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich

$13.99+

Deep Fried Chicken Strips, Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Lettuce and Tomato on Toasted Sourdough. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich.

Slash Pile Sandwich

$13.99+

Roasted Chicken Breast, Tomato, Spinach, Garlic White Sauce and Cheese on Toasted Sourdough. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Meatball Sandwich

$13.99+

Meatballs, our house blend of Cheese and Marinara Sauce on Toasted Sourdough. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Skidder Sandwich

$13.99+

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Bacon, our house blend of Cheese and Marinara Sauce on Toasted Sourdough Bread. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Gyro Sandwich

$13.99+

Gyro Meat, Tzatziki Sauce, Lettuce, Tomato and Cucumber on a Toasted Pita. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Gyro Sandwich.

Ultimate Reuben Sandwich

$14.99+

Corned Beef, Green Pepper, Onion, Sauerkraut, Green Olive, Jalapeno, Thousand Island and Garlic White Sauce on Toasted Marbled Rye or Sourdough Bread. Served with French Fries or a Side Salad.

Ultimate Reuben Sandwich.

Pasta and Lite Options

Looking for something light, try one of these options!

Kids Penne Pasta

$8.35

Penne Noodles with Spaghetti Sauce or Alfredo Sauce.

Kids Penne Pasta.

Chicken Strip Basket

$11.55+

3 Chicken Strips and French Fries or a Side Salad.

Chicken Strip Basket.

Spaghetti & Meatballs Penne Pasta

$12.50

Penne Noodles, Garlic Seasoning, Spaghetti Sauce, Two Meatballs, served with a slice of Garlic Bread.

Spaghetti & Meatballs Penne Pasta.

Chicken Alfredo Penne Pasta

$12.50

Penne Noodles, Chicken, Garlic Seasoning and Alfredo Sauce, served with a slice of Garlic Bread.

Chicken Alfredo Penne Pasta.

Kids Penne Pasta with Alfredo Sauce

$8.35

Penne Pasta with Alfredo Sauce

Salads

Dressing options: Ranch, Italian, Blue Cheese, French and Honey Mustard

Side Salad

$4.99

Fresh Greens, Tomato and Cheese with a side of Dressing. Gluten free.

Side Salad.

Mean Green Salad

$12.49

Fresh Greens, Onion, Tomato, Green Bell Pepper, Bacon and Cheese with a side of Dressing. Add Chicken $3.50

Mean Green Salad.

Roasted Italian Salad

$12.50

Fresh Greens, Tomato, Chickpeas, Pepperoni and Roasted Red Peppers. Add Chicken for $15.10.

Roasted Italian Salad.

Greek Goodness Salad

$15.49

Fresh Greens, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, Gyro Meat OR Chicken, Cheese and Tzatziki Sauce.

Greek Goodness Salad.

Beverages

Kids Fountain Drink

$2.30

Kids Fountain Drink.

Bottled Calypso Paradise Punch Lemonade

$4.49

Bottled Calypso Paradise Punch Lemonade.

Bottled Pure Leaf Sweet Tea

$4.49

Bottled Pure Leaf Sweet Tea.

Regular Fountain Drink

$3.35

Regular Fountain Drink.

Bottled Pure Leaf Raspberry Tea

$4.49

Bottled Pure Leaf Raspberry Tea.

Bottled Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea

$4.49

Bottled Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea.

Bottled Island Wave Lemonade

$4.49

Bottled Island Wave Lemonade.

Extra Sauces

Side sauce cups and extras.

Family Size Ranch

$8.60

16 oz Ranch, perfect for the whole family.

Side Honey Mustard

$0.55

Parm Packet

$0.00

Pepper Flake Packet

$0.00

Large Ranch

$1.05

Side Ranch

$0.55

Side French

$0.55

Side Tzatziki

$0.55

Side Mango Habanero

$0.55

Side BBQ

$0.55

Large Marinara

$1.05

Side Marinara

$0.55

Side Buffalo

$0.55

Side Thousand Island

$0.55

Side Italian

$0.55

Side Blue Cheese

$0.55

Side Garlic Parm

$0.55

Family Size Marinara

$8.60

Pizza Mill Retail

Pizza Mill Hat

$25.00

Navy Blue & Gray Trucker Hat with a leather logo patch

Pizza Mill Hat.

Pizza Mill Sticker

$2.00

Pizza Mill logo sticker, perfect for your water bottle or window

Pizza Mill Sticker.

6 Pack S’Mores Kit

$19.99

S’mores Ingredients for 6 Single S’Mores Sandwiches WNW S’mores kits are assembled by Westen, a four year old entrepreneur, and his mom. Westen has learned many things since starting his s’mores business, including how to handle food items, how to identify and count money, how to count and organize his inventory, and much more. Westen is learning to appreciate how much hard work goes into earning money for special purchases and saving for the future! Thank you for supporting a young entrepreneur! Please be sure to check the fire safety warnings in the area before starting a campfire. Can’t start a campfire? Try making your S’mores in the air fryer!

6 Pack S’Mores Kit.

12 Pack S’Mores Kit

$27.99

S’Mores Ingredients for 12 Single S’Mores Sandwiches WNW S’mores kits are assembled by Westen, a four year old entrepreneur, and his mom. Westen has learned many things since starting his s’mores business, including how to handle food items, how to identify and count money, how to count and organize his inventory, and much more. Westen is learning to appreciate how much hard work goes into earning money for special purchases and saving for the future! Thank you for supporting a young entrepreneur! Please be sure to check the fire safety warnings in the area before starting a campfire. Can’t start a campfire? Try making your S’mores in the air fryer!

12 Pack S’Mores Kit.

Pizza Peel Magnet

$5.00

Pizza Peel Magnet.
Custer

Menu

Our Story

Take N' Bake

More Information

We're Hiring

Gift Cards

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Pizza Mill, LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner